Project Information
City Council Approves Conversion of Carey Street from 2-way to 1-way
On October 19, 2026, City Council passed a resolution to convert Carey Street from 2-way to 1-way northbound, with the second lane to be converted into street parking. The full discussion can be found on the CTN YouTube recording of October 19 (see also the Carey Street PowerPoint Presentation).
Bridge & Northern Sections Now on Separate Page as Broadway-Plymouth Safety Improvements Project
As of September 21, 2026, the City Transportation Department has separated the Broadway Bridge & Plymouth Road elements from the Division Street Bikeway Extension Project to allow additional time to evaluate new conditions.
Details are available on the City-led Broadway-Plymouth Safety Improvements Project. Please see the Press Release for more info.
Update - Most Recent Documents
Overview
The Division Street Bikeway Extension will continue the two-way bikeway from Catherine Street to the south end of the Broadway Bridge, where it will connect to the Broadway Bridge side-path.
This project is a partnership between multiple City departments; collaboration increases overall efficiency and reduces the amount of time the road is under construction. The City Engineering Department will install a new water main and resurface Division Street from Catherine to Detroit Street in 2027. The DDA will install a two-way separated Bikeway and crosswalk improvements from Catherine Street to the south end of the Broadway Bridge.
Goals
- Support bicycle travel by extending safe bicycle infrastructure and connecting downtown to the Broadway Bridge and Ann Arbor’s north side.
- Make travel lanes clear and predictable for everyone using the road, improving safety for pedestrians, cyclists, and drivers.
- Implement speed management to enhance comfort and safety for non-motorized users, where appropriate
- Coordinate with water main upsizing and street resurfacing projects
- Connect and improve the safety and accessibility of downtown streets for all ages and abilities
- Meet the goals of the A2 Moving Together Toward Vision Zero Plan and the DDA’s Development Plan.
Funding
This project's funding is broken out by funding source.
The following are estimates based on earlier planning efforts. Final costs will be updated as the concept is refined and finalized once bids are received from contractors.
- Water main – (Detroit to Kingsley) replace and upsize the 1880’s water main: $500,000 (City Water Utility Fund)
- Street resurfacing – (Detroit to Catherine): $680,000 (City Street, Bridge, and Sidewalk Millage)
- Bikeway, new sidewalk and sidewalk adjustments, crosswalk improvements, parking bump-ins, RRFBs, Accessible Pedestrian Signals (APS), and transit stop upgrades: $2,050,000 (Ann Arbor DDA Tax Increment Financing (TIF)).
Project Area
2025 and Prior
- The 2025 Initial Conceptual Design is developed as a part of the Downtown Area Circulation Study.
- City Council approves the DDA’s 2026 Development Plan, extending the DDA Boundary north to Depot Street and the Broadway Bridge.
2026 – June
- The process of taking the concept plan and turning it into construction plans begins - the DDA kicks off the Division Bikeway Extension Project, from Catherine Street to the Broadway Bridge.
2026 - July
- The Transportation Department kicks off the Broadway Bridge & Plymouth Rd Sections in July. The projects are merged together to facilitate a smooth connection between them and to collaborate on public engagement events.
- Public walking tours and the open house are advertised to the public.
- The project team meets with other city departments and agencies (Fire, AAATA) to work through specific needs and requirements.
- An updated concept plan is developed for the upcoming walking tours.
2026 - August and September
- Walking Tour August 25 (Tuesday) at 5 p.m.,
- Walking Tour September 11 (Friday) at 1 p.m.,
- Public Body Meetings: September 16 (Wednesday). The project team presented to several of the city’s appointed boards and commissions and collected feedback:
Projects Split: September 18 (Friday). The City Transportation Department separated its project portion, Broadway/Plymouth Safety Improvements, to take additional time to evaluate new conditions related to Broadway and Plymouth Road.
- Division Bikeway Extension Informational Open House: September 23 (Wednesday) from 5-7 p.m., will be held at the DDA offices (located in the Kerrytown Shops on the 2nd floor, right next to V2V clothing boutique). The open house is focused only on the Division Bikeway Extension from Catherine to the Broadway Bridge.
- New events in November are scheduled for the Broadway/Plymouth Safety Improvements (the sections that include the Broadway Bridge and Plymouth Road).
2026 – October
- City Council Meeting: October 19 (Monday) at 7 p.m.
The resolution to change Carey Street from a 2-way road to a 1-way road with a parking lane (southbound lane closed) will be presented to council.
Prior Engagement
- Downtown Area Circulation Study
A collaboration between the DDA and City Transportation that involved multiple rounds of public engagement, informing the priorities for future capital improvements in the downtown area
- People-Friendly Streets Initiative engaged the public to get feedback on bike infrastructure throughout downtown. The DDA’s People-Friendly Streets (PFS) initiative began in 2018 – prioritizing people, placemaking, and resilience.
Data and Analysis
- Multiple transportation and safety analyses of different types have been conducted over the past 5 years as a part of the recent plans and studies. Most recently, two analyses were conducted as part of the Downtown Area Circulation Study (page 148, aka Appendices D and E).
- Bikeway Loop Safety Update 2025
Provides an overview of the crash data for the downtown bikeway loop in 2025.
Street Closure Information
There are no street closures for this project until construction begins in 2027.
FAQs
Frequently Asked Questions
1. How will this project make Division and the Broadway intersection safer?
Today, the Division Street Bikeway ends at Catherine Street, leaving people biking to and from the northside without a connection to the Broadway Bridge. The Broadway interchange has frequently been noted as an area of concern due to its complicated layout and limited sight lines, which impact safety and access for all people. To simplify this intersection and improve safety, we recommend converting Carey St to one-way (downhill) only.Lack of visibility and conflict points are a concern due to their role in crash risks, which affects the overall safety and use of the corridor. Inadequate sight distances mean that drivers do not have enough time to see an approaching vehicle and respond appropriately, making it more likely for a crash to occur. Additional conflict points increase the chance of experiencing a crash every time a movement is made, whether by the turning vehicle or by the approaching vehicle. Reduction in conflict points makes all users safer. Ensuring adequate sight distances reduces the severity of crashes by giving drivers more time to react. These concerns are considered wherever opportunities exist to improve the safety of the corridor for all users.
This is a long-standing concern for this location in particular, and we have heard through our public engagement process that many people walking and biking avoid this area altogether specifically due to the existing unsafe condition where Carey Street turns onto Division. When the Broadway Bridge was reconstructed in the late 90s, staff recommended closing both Carey Street vehicle lanes; City Council directed staff to maintain vehicle traffic and integrate Carey Street into the design. Most recently, this concern reemerged as part of the Downtown Area Circulation Study analysis.
We recommend eliminating the turn from Carey Street onto Division/the Broadway bridge for the following reasons:
- People driving uphill on Carey Street have a limited sight distance around the curve of Division. The horizontal curve and the retaining wall in front of 544 N Division can obstruct the sightline for the driver turning onto the bridge. This is particularly difficult to navigate with the increased speeds observed around the curve. The Carey Street turn does not meet the city’s current sight distance safety practice; meeting this is the baseline minimum expectation for all city projects to ensure safety for all people.
- There are multiple points of conflict at this intersection, including the pedestrian crossing immediately north of Carey. Drivers turning right and watching for a gap in traffic from their left may not see pedestrians crossing before turning across the crosswalk. In addition, cars pulling up ahead of the Carey stop bar to see around the curve create a stopping sight distance obstruction, preventing vehicles on Division from seeing pedestrians in the crosswalk just north of the intersection.
- Illegal movements, such as vehicles cutting across Division to get to Beakes, have been observed, which exacerbates the unsafe condition.
- The extension of the two-way bikeway / shared-use pathway will provide a low-stress bicycle route and a more accessible pedestrian connection to the bridge and encourage more walking and biking. This will create an additional point of conflict at the Carey/Division Street intersection if the Carey southbound lane is not closed.
2. Are you recommending closing Carey Street?
No. The recommendation is to change Carey Street from two-way to one-way, removing the ability to travel uphill on Carey Street (Depot to Division). Cars traveling to Depot or the hospital will still be able to drive northbound (downhill) on Carey Street to access Depot Street from Division Street.
3. Will the Division Bikeway Extension Project proceed if Carey Street is not converted to one-way?
No, the Division Bikeway Extension Project will not proceed if Carey Street remains two-way. After detailed consideration, the design team concluded that the turn from Carey Street onto Division is not in a safe condition today (see Question 01). Installing a bikeway extension and shared use path with this turn in place would add a conflict point between bikes, cars, and pedestrians at the Carey intersection, increasing the risk for everyone traveling through the intersection. We will not pursue a project that decreases safety in any part of the project area.
If Carey Street remains two-way, the bikeway extension will be deferred until the time that the city and DDA are able to completely reconfigure the Division-Beakes-Carey-High intersection. This project requires substantially higher investment and coordination and is not expected to occur in the next 10 years.
Please view the Project Concept Design (10.13.2026).
4. If Carey Street is changed to one-way only, eliminating the ability to drive from Depot to Division (uphill), where will drivers who currently use Carey to access Division go? Specifically, how will people who live north of Miller and west of Main access the north side?
Drivers traveling on Depot can use State Street or Fifth Avenue to access Kingsley Street in order to turn onto northbound Division. Those living west/northwest of downtown can also choose routes that include a combination of Summit, North Main, Felch, Kingsley, and Detroit Street.
Alternatives from Depot Street

Existing Conditions: Driving from Summit and Fountain Streets across the Broadway Bridge takes about 3-4 minutes today, but can take longer depending on traffic volumes on Depot St. Several alternatives exist in the current street network. For those driving from Depot to Carey to Division today, taking an alternative route could increase travel time by approximately 1-2 minutes. More details on example route options below.

Alternative A: Summit St to Main St to Depot to State to Kingsley to Division (approximately an additional 2 minutes of drive time from north of Miller):

an additional 2 minutes of drive time from north of Miller):

Alternative C: Spring St to Felch to Main St to Kingsley to Detroit or Division (approximately an additional 2 minutes of drive time from north of Miller):

Alternative D: Summit St to Main St to Depot to Fifth to Kingsley to Detroit or Division (approximately an additional 2 minutes of drive time from north of Miller):

To address possible wrong-way entries (people still trying to drive uphill), new signage would be added to the north end of Carey Street to alert drivers to the lane closure, such as permanent “Do Not Enter” and “Wrong Way” signs, and turn restriction signage for eastbound and westbound Depot Street traffic. In addition, temporary signs would be utilized for the initial implementation time to allow drivers to adjust to the change. These signs would read “NEW TRAFFIC PATTERN” and may have flags added to indicate that the traffic pattern on Carey Street has been changed.
5. How many cars go uphill, from Depot to Division, on Carey each day? What does that mean for the streets where that traffic would be displaced to?
The amount of traffic on Carey Street is small and can be accommodated by other streets without anticipated delays or safety issues. When a street is restricted to one way, traffic redistribution depends on several factors, including origin, capacity of the surrounding network, and driver behavior. In this case, people driving have a variety of ways to get northbound onto Division Street. Most scenarios include using Kingsley to access northbound Division Street through a combination of Summit, Main, Felch, Detroit, Fifth Ave, or State, as shown in the alternatives in the question above.
General Traffic Model Outcomes (Worst Case Scenario)
To understand the worst case scenario, traffic modeling was used to estimate what could happen if half of all drivers currently using Carey Street used Fifth Ave and the other half used State Street.

Table 01. Project Volume Changes (total vehicles in one hour)
| Map Number | Location | 2023 volumes from DAC | Rerouted volumes | Volume change | |||
| AM peak | PM peak | AM peak | PM peak | AM peak | PM peak | ||
| 1 | SB Fifth at Division | 73 | 104 | 124 | 134 | +51 | +30 |
| 2 | EB Kingsley at Division | 141 | 60 | 192 | 90 | +51 | +30 |
| 3 | SB State at Kingsley* | - | - | +51 | +29 | +51 | +29 |
| 4 | WB Kingsley at Division | 86 | 164 | 137 | 193 | +51 | +29 |
*Counts were not available at this location so just the change was shown.
Table 02. Projected Cars per Minute Change (vehicles per minute)
| Map Number | Location | 2023 cars per minute | Rerouted cars per minute | Cars per minute change | |||
| AM peak | PM peak | AM peak | PM peak | AM peak | PM peak | ||
| 1 | SB Fifth at Beakes | 1.2 | 1.7 | 2.1 | 2.2 | +0.9 | +0.5 |
| 2 | EB Kingsley at Division | 2.4 | 1.0 | 3.2 | 1.5 | +0.8 | +0.5 |
| 3 | SB State at Kingsley* | - | - | - | - | +0.9 | +0.5 |
| 4 | WB Kingsley at Division | 1.4 | 2.7 | 2.3 | 3.2 | +0.9 | +0.5 |
At Kingsley and Division in the AM Peak period, the additional traffic would mean an additional 1.5 seconds or less of delay at the intersection. There are no queueing impacts.
At Fifth and Beakes in the AM Peak period, if the Carey Street traffic was evenly distributed between Fifth and State, the additional 51 vehicles would mean an additional 26 seconds of delay at the intersection for southbound traffic and a maximum queue in the peak period of about 6 vehicles.
These results are if the traffic ONLY rerouted to those two routes. It does not take into consideration that Main St to Kingsley or Spring to Miller/Catherine/Detroit may also be used. This would cause the impacts at the surrounding intersections to be even less than stated above.
Table 03. Delay per Vehicle (seconds/vehicle)
| Map Number | Location | 2023 delay (seconds) | Rerouted delay (seconds) | Total delay change (seconds) | |||
| AM peak | PM peak | AM peak | PM peak | AM peak | PM peak | ||
| 1 | SB Fifth at Beakes | 30.8 | 43.0 | 57.3 | 67.0 | +26.5 | +24.0 |
| 2 | EB Kingsley at Division | 5.7 | 6.1 | 7.2 | 6.8 | +1.5 | +0.7 |
| 3 | SB State at Kingsley* | - | - | - | - |
|
|
| 4 | WB Kingsley at Division | 21.4 | 23.2 | 22.9 | 24.2 | +1.5 | +1.0 |
Table 04. Queuing Impacts (95th percentile, only 5% of the time will queue exceed this level during a normal peak hour)
| Map Number | Location | 2023 queue length (ft & cars) | Rerouted queue length (ft & cars) | Queue length change | |||
| AM peak | PM peak | AM peak | PM peak | AM peak | PM peak | ||
| 1 | SB Fifth at Beakes | 41’ 2.1 vehicles | 73’ 3.7 vehicles | 112’ 5.6 vehicles | 122’ 6.1 vehicles | +71’ +3.5 vehicles | +49’ +2.4 vehicles |
6. Are there safe alternatives to restricting Carey Street to a one-way? Can the Carey Street intersection be redesigned for safe two-way traffic? Or can other streets be changed to provide more direct access to Division?
In the short term, no, there are no safe alternatives to restricting Carey Street to a one-way. We recognize that over time, the area north of Kingsley, including portions of Fifth Ave, Division, Detroit, Summit, and Beakes Street, were made one-way and designed with restrictions that limit routes for drivers and makes access for people walking and biking unsafe. We also recognize that restricting Carey Street to a one-way requires drivers currently using it to choose an alternative route within this already complicated area.
Long-term, we recommend large-scale changes. For people driving, changes like restoring Fifth Ave, Division, and Beakes to two-way traffic can make navigation easier by providing more direct routes and improving flexibility. However, solving these complex issues requires significant design and funding that cannot be addressed within the planned Division Street Resurfacing Project.
In the short term, we recommend eliminating the safety concern (see Question 1) at Carey Street by converting it to one-way and providing a safe option for people walking and biking. While this change requires some drivers to use an alternative route to access the bridge, it is a practical near-term solution to ensure all people have safe access to and from downtown and the north side.
Background on Alternatives
A range of options were considered, including reducing Division to one lane, recommendations from the Lower Town Study, redesigning High Street to reverse the one-way direction, and broadening the project area to provide two-way access from Ann Street to Division. We also looked at maintaining two-way traffic on Carey Street and redesigning the intersection approach to improve visibility and safety. The Division Street curve and uphill retaining wall at 544 N Division significantly limit the ability to make changes to safely retain two-way traffic and fit within the scope of this project (see Figure 1 below).
At this location, the only feasible obstructions that could be removed or relocated would be signage and lighting, which would not improve the sight distance that is limited due to the existing retaining wall, which cannot be removed or redesigned. In addition, there is not adequate space or enough traffic volume using Carey Street to warrant a signal to be added. In addition, placing signals where not warranted by traffic volumes has been shown to increase all crashes.
We arrived at limiting Carey Street to one way and extending the Division Bikeway/shared use path because it is a practical near-term solution to ensure all people have safe access to and from downtown and the northside. Today, people that rely on riding a bike do not have safe access to the Broadway Bridge. Those who rely on walking must navigate an indirect and inaccessible route (see Figure 2 below). The proposed improvements will provide a new direct and accessible path from Division Street to the Broadway bridge.
Figure 1: View from Carey Street, uphill on Division

Figure 2: Existing pedestrian path with challenging slopes to navigate

Figure 3: Street-level view of the challenging sidewalk slopes people must navigate today

Figure 4: The existing single-direction bike lane tapers off downhill on Division
7. If Carey Street changes to one-way, can access be provided on a different street; for example, can High Street be changed to one-way from State to Division? Can Catherine or Ann be restored to two-way?
There are existing alternative routes to access the bridge (Question 6). Additional changes to the direction of alternative streets, or conversion to two-way, will require substantial redesign and funding that is not feasible to implement as part of this project but is being explored long term.
8. There doesn’t appear to be many recent crashes at the Carey Street uphill turn (Depot to Division). Why are we closing it if there hasn’t been a pedestrian or cyclist accident in the last 5 years?
Our goal is to be proactive rather than reactive. We can design this area to prevent crashes, rather than waiting for a crash to occur to implement change. This means recognizing patterns that may result in a crash (see Question 1), such as near misses and unsafe movements. In addition, with the proposed improvements, we anticipate more people walking and biking. Reducing future conflict points at a location with preexisting safety concerns is an important factor shaping the design direction.
In the last two years (2024-2025), there have been 8 documented property damage-only crashes within 100 feet of the Carey Street/Division intersection. These crashes are summarized:
- One angle crash between a vehicle northbound on Division St stopped for a pedestrian crossing and a vehicle exiting from Carey St onto Division St.
- Three rear-end crashes, with one crash involving a vehicle waiting for a pedestrian to cross.
- Two single motor vehicle crashes (one involving snowy road conditions on southbound Carey St)
- Two sideswipe same-direction crashes on Division St
The design team reviewed video from two hours in November 2023 and within those two hours found 11 wrong-way or illegal movements using Carey Street to cut across Division to get to Beakes Street and 6 near-miss incidents that could have resulted in a crash. In the AM peak, there were 11 pedestrians crossing at the crosswalk and 1 of those was a near miss (10% of pedestrian crossings). In the PM peak, there were 12 pedestrians crossing at the crosswalk and 3 of those were near misses (25% of the movement).
AM peak 1-hr
- 2 wrong-way movements
- 1 near miss with ped at crosswalk
- 1 near miss with vehicle
PM peak 1-hr
- 9 wrong-way movements
- 3 near misses with ped at crosswalk
- 1 near miss with vehicle
Many studies support the claim that adequate sight distance reduces crash severity, including an NCHRP report, Guidance for Evaluating the Safety Impact of Intersection Sight Distance. The NCHRP report states that “target crash frequencies increase as available ISD [Intersection Sight Distance] decreases”.
9. Carey Street downhill (northbound) feels like a highway off-ramp today. How will you slow the speeds of cars using the downhill lane?
The Carey-High intersection will be redesigned so that the
right turn off Division is more perpendicular, forcing drivers to slow down to
turn, while
still providing the minimum radius for transit vehicles to navigate the turn
onto Carey Street.
It will also include a speed table/raised crosswalk to moderate speeds and
improve safety. Lastly, a slight shift in the travel lane to accommodate
on-street parking will further slow vehicles. Together, these measures will
deter cars from speeding down Carey or treating the turn like “a highway
off-ramp.”
10. Why are this project's recommendations different from the Lower Town Study?
While the Lower Town Mobility Study was helpful for its engagement and existing conditions analysis, the design recommendations did not strongly consider Vision Zero, site distance standards, and transit access to Depot Street and the Amtrak Station. In addition, the traffic modeling for the study was based on pre-pandemic data from 2019, which does not reflect current travel patterns and more recent vehicle counts.
The recommended alternatives in the Lower Town Study are as follows:
· Short-term recommendation – Option E: Continue the existing northbound bicycle lane up to Carey Street.
· Long-term recommendation – Option D: Reconfigure the entire intersection to slow the turn northbound from Division to Carey, eliminate the turn from Division to Summit (as well as the Detroit Street slip lane), and reduce the curve radius for Division to help with speeds.
The short-term Option E reflects a slight improvement to northbound accommodations for people biking and does not provide a low-stress, separated bicycle connection. The Downtown Area Circulation Study (completed in 2025, after the Lower Town Study) identified the need for short- and long-term solutions for low-stress bicycle connections on key corridors, which aligns with this current project’s goals.
The longer-term Option D maintains Carey as two-way, but achieves this by reconfiguring the curb lines of the entire intersection to separate High Street and Carey Street. For Carey Street, the recommended reduction to the Division St curve would improve preexisting sightline concerns, but they would not be solved completely, particularly with the addition of the shared use path across the intersection. The recommended corner geometry for the Carey St intersection is an improvement; however, the current project must consider the ability for transit (buses) to navigate down to the Amtrak station, which requires a wider turn radius.
The current Division Street project is intended to be a short-term safety improvement for the intersection and for people walking, biking, and driving, while more long-term intersection changes continue to be explored.
In addition, traffic volumes on Carey St were collected in November 2023. They show that travel patterns have changed. Additionally, there has been a reduction in traffic on Carey St since the Lower Town Study was conducted. The differences are outlined below:
- Lower Town Study (2019): AM Peak Hour: 208 vehicles, PM Peak Peak Hour: 73 vehicles
- DAC volumes (2023): AM Peak Hour: 102 vehicles, PM Peak Hour: 59 vehicles
See the Downtown Area Circulation Study for additional background.
11. Some of the early concept plans showed a 2-way bike lane instead of a parking lane on Carey Street. Why were the plans changed?
In consultation with the cycling community, riders expressed that they avoid Carey Street if possible because the uphill journey is unpleasant and difficult. Those who ride downhill expressed that they are comfortable using the sidewalk or road, due to the low volume of cars and pedestrians. Others expressed that Carey did not provide a meaningful connection to existing bike facilities, and that planned connections through Broadway Park West and 721 N. Main provide better alternatives. Residents of the adjacent neighborhood also expressed a desire to incorporate more on-street parking if possible.
In addition, installing a best-practice bikeway on Carey St is challenging, which would result in a very narrow buffer and issues installing vertical delineation due to the brick.
For these reasons, the bike lane was replaced with parking.
12. Some of the early concept plans showed one travel lane on Division Street from Catherine Street to the Broadway Bridge. Why were the plans changed? How will the latest concept plan slow speeds and improve safety?
The recommended concept in the Downtown Area Circulation Study included two travel lanes on Division Street plus a two-way bikeway and some on-street parking. Early in this final design phase, we shared a one-vehicle lane concept that was based on discussions with the Transportation Department and Fire Department about using the two-way bikeway as an emergency access lane. This was a new concept both locally and nationally.
Subsequently, the Fire Department determined this was not a safe solution due to shared concerns about creating dangerous conflicts between first responder vehicles and people biking. Given that safety is an important project goal, we shifted our attention back to the two-vehicle lane concept. To encourage slow, safe speeds while maintaining two-vehicle lanes, we are looking to the success of our Fifth Avenue and Detroit Street Improvements. We are exploring similar pedestrian medians as well as pedestrian crosswalk flashers (RRFBs), raised crosswalks, and other traffic calming tools. We feel confident that a combination of these treatments plus an extended two-way bikeway will be a significant safety improvement. The design team is currently exploring the best combination of treatments within the project limits and street constraints, and we plan to post an updated conceptual design the week of October 12th.
13. Why isn’t there an online engagement tool in addition to the in-person engagement options?
Substantial engagement – including online engagement – was conducted as a part of the Downtown Area Circulation (DAC) Study to inform the concept design for the Division Bikeway. The engagement summary has been added to the project website under the “Previous Studies and Plans” section. After the extensive engagement conducted for the DAC, the focus of this phase of the Division Bikeway engagement was to refine the design details with nearby neighbors and stakeholders. We recognize that presenting the more developed Division Bikeway Extension design together with the newer Broadway/Plymouth Safety Improvements Project caused confusion. You can now find details and provide input into the Broadway-Plymouth Safety Improvement Project on the Project Engage Page.
14. By adding parking on Carey, what is the total change in the number of street parking spaces for the Division Bikeway Project?
The project goal is to provide approximately the same number of parking spaces that currently exist, which is achieved by adding Carey Street parking. The current design shows a net change in on-street parking spaces for this project of +1. However, this may change as the design details are refined. The final total number of street parking spaces will be determined closer to final design.
15. Will the parking on Carey Street be residential permit parking?
The on-street parking on Carey Street will not be metered/paid parking. By default, the parking will be regular, unrestricted street parking. If residents of the adjacent neighborhood are interested in permit parking, they can petition the City to implement the residential parking program as long as the Council-approved criteria are met. This project does not control whether the block meets the criteria or whether the immediate neighborhood wishes to apply.
16. If I am driving downhill (northbound) on Carey Street, what is the risk of rear-ending someone as they try to parallel park on the hill?
Based on 1) the speed-control measures proposed for the Carey-High intersection, and 2) the crash data from comparable steep roads in Ann Arbor, the risk of rear-ending someone as they parallel park on Carey is expected to be small.
- The Carey-High intersection will be redesigned so that the right turn off of Division is more perpendicular, forcing drivers to slow down to turn. It will also include a speed table/raised crosswalk to moderate speeds and improve safety. In addition, a slight shift in the travel lane to accommodate the parking will further slow vehicles. These three measures will deter cars from speeding down Carey or treating the turn like “a highway off-ramp."
- An analysis of other steep streets in Ann Arbor demonstrates that rear-end crashes with parallel parking cars on steep slopes are exceptionally rare. Crashes where someone rear-ends a car that is parallel parking are classified as “rear-end” on the city-wide crash map.
Other areas of steeper parallel street parking in Ann Arbor (rear-end crashes in the last 5 years):
- Ridgeway Street – 0 crashes
- Harvard Place – 0 crashes
- Nichols Drive – 0 crashes
- Mullholland Avenue – 0 crashes
- Murray Avenue – 0 crashes
- S 3rd Street – 0 crashes
- Sunset Road – 0 crashes
- Traver Road, south of Barton – 0 crashes
- Doty Avenue – 0 crashes
- Westwood Avenue – 0 crashes
- W Summit Street, between Daniel and Hiscock – 0 crashes
- N 5th Avenue – 0 crashes
- N 4th Avenue – 0 crashes
- Elizabeth Street, north of school entrance – 0 crashes
- Daniel Street – 0 crashes
- N State Street – 2 crashes
- Crash #1 – a vehicle rear-ended an already-parked vehicle during dry, daylight conditions while heading south (uphill).
- Crash #2 – a vehicle rear-ended another moving vehicle during dry, daylight conditions while heading south (uphill).
- E Ann Street, Ingalls to Glen – 0 crashes
- Devonshire Road – 0 crashes
Staff will track speeds, volumes, and crashes after implementation to determine if adjustments are required.
17. Will the brick on State Street be removed and replaced with asphalt because of the cars displaced from Carey Street?
Because the estimated volumes are low, we do not foresee any damage to the brick road on State, and pre-emptive removal of the bricks to replace them with asphalt is not warranted. The State Street brick road is also a valued part of the Old Fourth Ward Historic District, and its preservation contributes to the character of the neighborhood.